| Instructor: Dr. Mark V. Barrow, Jr. Office: 432 Major Williams Phone: 231-4099 (O), 552-5876 (H) Office Hours: T, Th 11-12 p.m., and by appt. E-Mail: barrow@vt.edu Homepage: http://majbill.vt.edu/history/barrow/hist4224/ Class listserv: HIST4244_16011@listserv.vt.edu |
Such is the economy of nature, that no instance can be
produced of her having permitted any one race of her animals to become extinct;
of her having formed any link in her great work so weak as to be broken. --Thomas Jefferson |
Objectives:
In 1973, Congress passed the Endangered Species Act, a sweeping and (as it turned
out) controversial environmental initiative. This course examines the deep history
of that act, beginning in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, when scholars
debated whether extinction can actually occur. In addition to exploring the
stories of several lost or vanishing species, readings will examine the individuals,
ideas, institutions, and policies that have developed around the threat of wildlife
extinction, with a special focus on the role of naturalists. This course, which
has been developed out of the instructor's current research project, uses readings,
videos, student-led discussions, writing assignments, and a major research paper
to explore how Americans have tried to grapple with the issue of wildlife extinction.
Requirements:
1. Attendance and Participation:
This class is designed to facilitate
active learning and give students a primary role in the presentation and discussion
of class material. To achieve these goals, students are expected to attend each
class meeting, to complete the assigned reading before class, and to
offer informed contributions to the class discussion.
2. Weekly Analytical Reaction Papers:
To sharpen writing skills, help focus ideas, and facilitate discussion, on most
weeks during the first half of the semester each participant will turn in a
short (ca. 1 p., double spaced) analytical reaction paper. While I may occasionally
assign specific topics for these papers, in most cases you will be given wide
latitude in how you approach this assignment. You may assess the strengths and
weaknesses of the assigned reading, respond to its major arguments, critically
examine its theoretical and/or methodological frameworks, relate it to other
readings for the course, or some combination of these approaches. Simple summaries
will not suffice; analytical reaction papers must come to terms with the significance
and meaning of the reading. I want you to demonstrate that you have read
and given serious thought to the material for that week. Regardless of the particular
strategy you adopt for doing this, your reaction papers should also be concise,
well-written, and carefully proofread. Reaction papers will be graded using
an informal check/check+/ check- evaluation system. Occasionally we may also
do peer evaluations of them. Reaction papers must be turned in by the beginning
of the class in which they are due to receive credit; failure to turn in reaction
papers will result in a grade of zero for that assignment.
3. Discussion Anchors:
Each week one or more volunteers (depending
on the final size of the class) will be responsible for leading class discussion.
Discussion anchors are expected to be especially familiar with the reading for
the day and to compose a set of questions to help guide our discussions. A single
set of discussion questions (which should be jointly constructed when there
are two or more discussion anchors) must be posted on the class listserv no
later than twenty-four hours before class. During class discussion anchors will
not only be responsible for leading discussion, but also be available to answer
questions, share resources, and summarize major arguments of the reading. No
formal presentation is necessary, but discussion anchors may provide a brief
introduction to the discussion if they wish. Creative discussion formats (e.g.,
class debates, in-class group projects, etc.) are welcome.
4. Research Paper:
All participants in the seminar are required to complete a ca. 15 page double
spaced (or ca. 4000 word or so) paper on a topic of their choice (made in consultation
with the instructor). The paper must be based on original research and use a
broad range of appropriate primary and secondary source materials. It should
also contain proper documentation (notes and bibliography) cited in the standard
format historians generally use (i.e., the styles in the most recent editions
of Kate Turabian, Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses, or Dissertations
or The Chicago Manual of Style). Early initiation and consistent effort
throughout the term are crucial to the production of a successful paper. To
encourage students to begin working early and to provide opportunities for feedback
from others in the course, participants will occasionally be asked to report
to the class on how their work is progressing. In addition, a preliminary topic
choice, an abstract /working bibliography, and an initial draft are due according
to the schedule below. At one of the sessions near the end of the semester,
students will formally present their research to the rest of the class. The
final paper is due on the last day of class (see schedule, below).
Some potential ideas for research paper topics include the history of:
5. Reading:
The following books should be at the University Bookstore,
Volume Two Bookstore, and the Tech Bookstore. They may also be purchased online
(at, e.g., amazon.com, bn.com, bookfinder.com, or half.com). In addition I have
placed copies of them on reserve at Newman Library.
In addition to the assigned books, supplemental readings will occasionally be posted on the Web. These are indicated on the schedule, below.
6. Grades:
Grades for the course will be based on the following:
| Attendance and participation | 20% |
| Reaction papers | 20% |
| Discussion anchor | 7.5% |
| Abstract and bibliography | 7.5% |
| Draft research paper | 10% |
| Research presentation | 10% |
| Final research paper | 25% |
A Personal Note:
I am here to help you learn. Please feel free to contact me if you have
any questions, concerns, special needs, or difficulties related to this course
(or even if you just want to talk about the issues it raises). I know that approaching
a professor can be intimidating, but I want to assure you that I enjoy meeting
with students, and I do everything possible to make myself accessible.
Schedule:
Subject to revision as necessary (any changes will be announced in class and
posted on the class homepage). Reading assignments are to be completed by the
time of class on the day they are listed below. Unless otherwise noted, the
numbers in the reading assignment column refer to chapters. On-line readings
are marked as OLR, and are available on the class homepage. The user name for
on-line readings is: walden and the password is: pond.
| Date | Topic | Reading | Assignment |
| 1/20 | Introduction | ||
| 1/27 | Discovering Extinction | OLR: Barrow Draft Chapters 1, 2, 3, and Bibliography | ARP |
| 2/3 | The Bison I | Isenberg, Intro., 1-3 | ARP |
| 2/10 | The Bison II | Isenberg 4-6, conclusion | ARP |
| 2/17 | Avian Extinctions | Cokinos Intro, 1-5, 9 | ARP |
| 2/24 | Protecting Predators I | Dunlap 1-7 | ARP |
| 3/2 | Protecting Predators II | Dunlap 8-Epilogue | ARP |
| Spring Break | |||
| 3/16 | The ESA and Its Critics | OLR | Abstract and Biblio |
| 3/23 | TBA | ||
| 3/30 | Progress Reports | ||
| 4/6 | Progress Reports | ||
| 4/13 | Progress Reports | Draft Paper | |
| 4/20 | Presentations | ||
| 4/27 | Presentations | ||
| 5/4 | Final Paper | Final Paper |